Should You Ditch Written Goals?

Nearly every motivational guru will tell you , "Youhad conquered all the known (to Western Europeans)
have to have written goals." I've even said soworld? Where were the written goals of the
myself, "If you're not committed enough to yourfounders of the United States: Adams, Jefferson,
goals enough to put it in writing, you're notFranklin, Washington and others? Were are Lincoln's
committed enough to your goals to achieve them.written goals? Fredrick Douglas? What about George
Brian Tracy gives further proof of the importance ofWashington Carver, Madame Curie, Nicolai Tesla, or
written goals. In his book Goals! he reports on aEdison? Where are their written goals? There is no
study that reveals just how effective written goalsrecord of them.
can be. According to Tracy in a Harvard studyIn any field of endeavor, science, literature, art,
conducted between 1979 and 1989, the graduates ofsports, military, politics, religion, or any other, think of
the MBA program were asked, "Have you set clear,the people who were or are most successful. I
written goals for your future and made plans tochallenge you to find a list of written goals. You may
accomplish them?" Only 3 percent of the graduatesfind their goals stated in correspondences or articles
had written goals and plans. Thirteen percent hadthey have written. You might even find in their
goals, but not in writing. Fully 84 percent had nojournals statements of what they are hoping to
specific goals at all.accomplish. What you won't find is a "to-do" list of
Ten years later, in 1989, the researchers found thataccomplishments or acquisitions. They didn't, as many
the 13 percent who had goals that were not inmotivational gurus advise, write out their goals. They
writing were earning twice as much as the 84certain place sticky notes with their written goals
percent of students who had no goals at all. Mostaround their house as reminders.
surprisingly, they found that the 3 percent ofWhat about the most successful people today? Do
graduates who had clear, written goals when theythey have written goals? Possibly so since the myth
left Harvard were earning, on average, 10 times asof written goals has been around for several decades
much as the other 97 percent of graduates allnow. Would they have written goals were it not for
together. The only difference between the groupsthe myth of the importance of written goals? Would
was the clarity of the goals they had for themselvesthey be any less successful without them?
when they graduated.The difference between success and mediocrity, and
Did you catch that? The 3 percent who had clear,between mediocrity and failure is not something so
written goals earned ten times as much as the 97banal as written goals.
percent who didn't have clear, written goals. If thatSuccessful people have targets, and have ends
does convince you of the importance of written(goals) which they strive towards. There's something
goals what does?more important than goals. They have a passion for
Pretty impressive until you start to look more intowhat they are doing, and they are "in-love with" the
this study and ask a few questions. Why is it thatideal they are striving towards.
various motivational gurus tell different versions ofSuccessful people do not need written goals to keep
the study. In some versions the study took place atthem on track, just as if you are in-love with another
Yale. In some versions it took place in the mid-50syou don't need a written goal of spending time with
Search academic data bases, and you won't find thehis or her beloved. Their actions and intentions
study. Apparently, there was no such study. It is aembody the goal. The desire for the goal is within
myth that writers and speakers continue to handthem. Written goals can serve as a way to
down as it were fact. The study just isn't true. It'scommunicate the ideal to others, but no reminder is
not enough to say as Tracy has been reported toneeded.
say, "If it's not true it should be."Are written goals essential for success? No. Helpful?
This myth brings up are a number of naggingPossibly yes. Harmful? Probably not. The ability to
unanswered questions. As an avid reader ofcommunicate your goals to others is important. In our
biographies and autobiographies I was curious aboutculture writing is one tool for clarifying our own ideas
the goals of famous people. I noted the conspicuousand communicating it to others. Goals and targets are
lack of written goals. If written goals are soimportant, but written goals are a weak substitute
important, where were the written goals of thesefor passion. If you need written reminders to keep
people whose lives impacted history? Where are theyou on track for your goals, could it be your goals
written goals of Alexander the great, who by age 33and your passions don't match?